We have had this same issue over the past few days with little help from Paypal. They told us we had to call atom tickets. We did and they say have no record of any charges to our account. Contacted PayPal. Escalated it. Got a snotty email back that said they determined there was "No unauthorized use" and that it is "consistent with our previous purchases". And that "Moving forward please be sure to review our active billing agreements." We don't buy from Atom tickets. We don't even buy tickets online. Even if we had, we definitely aren't making 20+ purchases of varying amounts in one day. Should be pretty apparent to a company that deals with finance. After writing them a snappy email, arguing with them on the phone that it was definitely not us and we reported it as fraud. They decided to "Transition our case to the right category to help you get your refund" where they reported it as goods not received. But they refuse to admit it is fraud, and they still think it's 100% our fault. We removed all our cards from Paypal and won't use them ever again. Unfortunately we aren't in the position to have tons of money just come out of our account. They also refused to acknowledge that this is clearly an ongoing issue.
